St Mary's Parish Magazine November 2026
A Crisis Averted – Or Is It?
I was relieved to read that the more grandiose elements of the hall development plan have been abandoned and that the thinking is now in tune with the original suggestion, made many years ago, that kitchen and toilet improvements are the priority.
On at least two occasions I have written articles for this magazine pointing out the folly of the original plan and have also challenged it at parish meetings.
To suggest that an ageing, and diminishing, congregation could raise the sum of £1.2 million with no appreciable assets, either in terms of money or saleable land or buildings, was unrealistic. So was the idea of match funding as the rate at which we could raise funds, and the amount being raised at each attempt, was pathetically small.
We were told, at some point in the proceedings, that we had a member of the congregation who had had experience in this field but it transpired that this was linked to a small- scale project. Had we had a brace of investment bankers, a hedge-fund manager, an architect, a solicitor and the boss of a construction firm in the congregation things might have been different
My objections to the plan were based on all of the above but, more crucially, because I had been involved in a similar situation many years earlier when I was warden of St. Margarets’ Church in Upper Norwood. It was decided that we would install a mezzanine floor in the church and thought that we had enough cash to fulfil the project but the architects kept insisting on this survey being done and that improvement considered until we ran out of cash and abandoned the project. The only winners were the architects.
Does that sound familiar? Tens of thousands of pounds have been spent on architects’ fees in relation to the current project.
Now my question is this. Why was this project not halted before too much financial damage was done? Why didn’t someone in the Dioscesen Office query the plan. Surely the treasurer was aware of St. Mary’s resources, attendance records and earnings potential.
And why didn’t those members of the PCC who had doubts about the scheme’s viability object? Or perhaps they did object and were either overruled or ignored. I don’t know how the PCC operates because a) I am not a member and b) it seems to me that very little news of PCC deliberations and decisions filters down to members of the congregation.
Continued ...